Why your waste costs 20 times more than you think

Waste disposal costs are rising.  Heightened attention is being turned to dealing with it cost-effectively, diverting it from landfill and getting the best possible income stream from recycling or re-using it.  This attention to waste is a good thing.  We want to reduce the cost of it, to make our businesses more competitive.  However the truth is that most managers are missing 95% of the cost of their waste.  If your facility’s waste costs were 20 times higher than you thought, what action would you take?

The answer is obvious – you would stop trying to maximise the recycling and re-use value of your waste stream.  Instead, you’d try to stop producing it in the first place.

Let’s look at a hypothetical manufacturing company[i].  Imagine a firm that produces high quality ready meals.  Our firm has operating costs of £50 million a year, and runs two shifts a day.  They produce 500 tonnes of waste per year, and it costs them £100 per tonne to dispose of it (fees and handling costs).  So this firm believes that its cost of waste is £50,000 per year.  This is significant enough to get attention, but at just 0.1% of total cost, it is not the highest priority.

Now, imagine that each day, an average of 10 minutes of each 8-hour shift produces waste.  This takes two main forms: 

• Occasional quality failures (e.g. too little product in one tub, or a run with wrong dates)
• Planned waste, while a new run is started, and the machines are adjusted to get the machines aligned perfectly

So for an average of 20 minutes per day (10 minutes for each of two shifts), the facility is producing waste.  That’s roughly 2% of a 16 hour day.  In other words, 2% of the operational time, and therefore 2% of the operational cost (electricity, people, facilities costs, materials, etc) is waste.  In a facility that costs £50 million per year to run, that’s a cost of £1 million, spent on producing product that will never be sold.

This is just a hypothetical example.  Is it typical?  In fact, this is close to the average for the UK economy as a whole.  As I’ve reported elsewhere, DEFRA estimates there are £23 billion of resource efficiency savings with a year payback or less, just waiting for firms to take advantage of them – about 1.6% of GDP.

A million pounds of a £50 million budget is a substantial sum – it could be better spent holding off the next round of unwanted redundancies, investing in new capital equipment, or developing new products.  If this were your firm, wouldn’t you do whatever you could to stop the waste?

So... just how much of your operational time each day is spent producing waste?

---

[i] This could apply just as well to a service company.  For example, in a call centre, it might include outbound calls to wrong numbers, and times when the computers or phone lines are down.

How much is this waste costing us?

Nowadays, waste disposal costs usually have a place in the accounts.  Standard landfill tax costs £56 per tonne (set to rise to £80 per tonne by 2014), and waste disposal services have their fixed and variable fees on top.  Recycling may provide some relief, but still typically involves some cost.  However, waste has hidden costs as well, and these can be considerably more than the disposal or recycling cost.

There are two big hidden costs in waste: the materials, and the production cost.  The first is easier to spot – if you purchase a tonne of steel, and sell products containing 990g of steel, you know you have wasted 1% of the material.  Production managers are usually aware of this, but the finance department may not be.

The second cost is less obvious – the cost of the facility.  Let’s say that a manufacturing firm has operating costs of £100m per year, and is working fairly near its current capacity, so waste products displace products that could be sold.  If the reject rate is 0.1% of products, then the operating cost of producing that waste is £100K per year (0.1% of £100m).  Alternatively, consider this from a time perspective.  If a typical production line in our hypothetical facility spends just 10 minutes of a 16 hour day producing product that can’t be sold, that would be 1% of the time – or £1m cost per year.  Move to another perspective: the opportunity cost of the goods not produced because the line is at capacity.  If gross margins are just 10%, then waste at 1% of production is equivalent to £100K of foregone profit, displaced by waste.

These hidden costs of waste are rarely part of any management accounting system, and may be difficult to pin down.  However it’s worth the effort – keeping track, even at the “guestimate” level, can help companies work out the value of investing in waste elimination initiatives.  Putting a price on waste helps to focus attention on a big win for both the environment and the bottom line.  Recycling may deal with the waste that can’t be eliminated, but the biggest win comes from avoiding waste entirely.